Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pulled Pork Burger
Hot Tea
White Supreme Pizza (16" Large)
White Tomato Pizza (10" Personal)
About
Original Italian Pizza - St Clair
Welcome to Original Italian Pizza - St Clair, a hidden gem located at 59 N 2nd St, St Clair, PA 17970. This neighborhood pizza haven may not catch your eye from the street, but step inside, and you’ll discover a world of flavors that pizza lovers rave about. With a friendly ambiance and dedicated staff, it’s no wonder that this establishment has become a go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike.
Don’t let its unassuming exterior fool you; the interior reflects a cozy charm, setting the stage for a delightful dining experience. Customers like Michael Zellner frequently visit, often picking up pies for workplace gatherings. His praise highlights the consistent quality of pizza that has earned Original Italian Pizza a loyal following; the combination of fresh toppings and a unique sauce that offers both distinct flavor and sweetness is consistently lauded.
One standout on the menu is the Shrimp Alfredo. As noted by Sam Botham, with a little extra garlic, it transforms into a must-try dish that keeps patrons coming back. While some reviews mention pizzas that are occasionally underbaked, the staff is committed to correcting any oversight, making sure each experience is better than the last.
For those searching for top-tier pizza on the east coast, look no further! Original Italian Pizza - St Clair pursues fresh ingredients and endless creativity, with customers like miny thanos ranking it amongst the best. Whether you prefer traditional toppings or something unique, you’ll find options that cater to all palates. And let’s not forget about their gluten-free offerings, which even skeptics appreciate!
In conclusion, if you find yourself craving authentic Italian pizza, this is a must-visit. The atmosphere may be simple, but the flavors are anything but. With its stellar customer service and a menu that consistently surprises, Original Italian Pizza - St Clair is not just a pit stop; it’s a destination for deliciousness. We recommend giving it a try for your next pizza night! Don’t forget to call ahead at +1 570-429-0120.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ If i passed this on the street, probably wouldn't look twice. I found this by accident basically and looked worth trying, even had a GF option, which is usually cringe, but you do what you have to, right?! I didn't try it hot, just put it in the fridge due to timing of dinner. The bad: Average atmosphere I didn't eat in, but friendly staff I'm very happy I tried it! This is the top 5 places for pizza I've had on the east coast. I've been looking for good pizza and they just all fall short. I'm excited to try this again hot, because cold it's Loaded with toppings, sauce has a distinct flavor and sweetness to it, FRESH TOPPINGS Keep it up!!! ”
“ I've been here several times to pick up pizza for my wife's office when I have been off during the day. While not much to look at from the outside, they really have the inside looking pretty nice. The pizza is great, it's why my wife's office keeps requesting it. I normally grab something for my lunch as well and I have never been disappointed. The staff have always been awesome ”
“ I have to say, their pizzas always come under baked. I have to cook it further in my oven. But tonight, they made a dish I'll order everyday (as long as made the same) get the shrimp Alfredo, ask for fresh garlic (it's an upcharge and shouldn't be, but it is worth it, I promise) I got 8 shrimp (which come on is a lot for a restaurant) they forgot my fries, but they delivered them in perfect time. Bottom line, we are all human and will fix our my mistakes, and they do. I was about to right them off, but after my dinner tonight (and I am picky beyond all y'all) ”
“ We love all of the really great items on the menu. The food is always consistent and good. ”
“ The food was great, waitress was great, masks mandatory to enter and at this point in time, that means they value the safety of themselves and community. We will be back next time we're in the Pottsville area! ”
“ Coming from out of the area, you wouldn't know you need to stop here to have absolutely delicious food and hot freshly made rolls! The service was absolutely wonderful! The pizza came out fast and hot. The minestrone soup was seasoned perfectly. I highly recommend and will definitely be back when we're in the area. If anything though, you really have to try the rolls!!! ”
“ Was warmly welcomed by multiple people and had quick friendly service. The food was absolutely delicious and the restaurant was very clean/ including the restrooms. ”
“ My rating is based on their pizza. I haven’t had anything else. Very good! Tasty, tastes like real authentic pizza. The sauce is Yum, good amount of cheese in proportion to sauce. Crust is just the right thickness and texture and their portions are very generous. I go out of my way to get their pizza. ”